Second Degree Murder Penalties and Sentencing
After a jury has found a defendant guilty of second degree murder, the case moves on to the sentencing phase. During this phase, the defendant will learn what penalties the state or federal government will impose for their crime.
There are several factors that determine what sentence a person convicted of second degree murder will receive. First, there is the actual language of the law that sets the penalty. Second, there is a range of aggravating and mitigating factors that courts can consider when deciding on a sentence. All of these things taken together will determine what punishment a defendant receives.
The Letter of the Law
The statutes that specifically outlaw second degree murder will generally contain some discussion of the appropriate punishments for the crime. Usually this takes the form of a general time period, such as 15 years to life. Oftentimes, however, the discussions dont contain much specific information about the sentences, and give courts wide latitude to determine penalties.
For example, the federal statute criminalizing second degree murder states that [w]hoever is guilty of murder in the second degree, shall be imprisoned for any term of years or for life. This vague sentencing declaration compels federal judges to use the Federal Sentencing Guidelines in order to determine an appropriate punishment for a person convicted of second degree murder.
Other jurisdictions statutes give specific punishments for certain situations. For instance, Californias Penal Code sets out specific minimum punishments for second degree murder when committed against a peace officer or when resulting after shooting a firearm from a motor vehicle.
Aggravating and Mitigating Factors
In addition to elements set out in the penal code, there are usually a number of aggravating and mitigating factors that courts examine to determine a defendants exact sentence.
Aggravating factors are aspects of the crime or the criminals behavior or history that increase the severity of the imposed sentence. Mitigating factors tend to demonstrate to the sentencing court that the defendant deserves a lighter sentence than they would normally receive without the presence of the mitigating factors.
These factors vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, but most jurisdictions will examine a few basic factors when deciding on punishments.
In the federal system, for example, under the Federal Sentencing Guidelines, a judge can increase a second degree murder sentence if the defendants conduct was exceptionally heinous, cruel, brutal, or degrading to the victim. Other aggravating factors include a defendants criminal history, whether the crime constituted a hate crime, and whether the defendant used a firearm in the commission of the crime.
Federal mitigating factors include whether or not the defendant has accepted responsibility for the crime, any mental or physical illnesses the defendant has, the defendants civic contributions and the nature of the defendants childhood.
States also examine similar aggravating and mitigating factors when determining the penalties for second degree murder.
As with most aspects of the law, the exact procedure will depend on where the trial occurs. Generally, however, the court will hold a hearing at some point after the conviction to examine the nature of the offense and weigh the aggravating and mitigating factors. After deliberation, the court will hand down the defendants sentence.