Second Degree Murder Defenses
There are several defenses that could apply to a second degree murder charge. Most defendants assert that they didn't actually commit the crime. Other defendants admit to killing the victim, but claim some sort of justification. Attorneys call these types of defenses affirmative defenses. As with most criminal cases, the result of a defense strategy will depend on the facts surrounding the charges and the laws of the jurisdiction. Read on to learn about the most common defenses that could apply to an allegation of second degree murder.
Second Degree Murder Defenses: Actual Innocence
The most common defense that defendants raise is that they didn't perpetrate the crime. This defense can involve several elements, including the presentation of an alibi or challenges to the prosecution's evidence. The prosecution has the burden of proof, and must demonstrate beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant committed the killing. Thus, if the defendant can raise a doubt about their guilt in the minds of the members of the jury, there's a good chance the jury will find them not guilty of the charge.
Second Degree Murder Defenses: Insanity
The insanity defense isn't available in all jurisdictions, but most jurisdictions allow it. Even where it is available, however, an insanity defense won't necessarily relieve a defendant of all responsibility for a second degree murder charge. Some jurisdictions recognize that a defendant has a mental illness, but still knew that their actions were wrong or prohibited at the time the crime took place. These jurisdictions often have a verdict of guilty but mentally ill, which means that, despite their mental illness, the defendant had control over their actions when the killing occurred.
In the jurisdictions that do accept the full insanity defense, if a defendant can show that they fit the legal definition of insanity at the time of the killing, the law will generally not hold them accountable for their actions. The legal definition of insanity varies between jurisdictions, and there are several different tests to show insanity.
Second Degree Murder Defenses: Self-Defense
When a slaying occurs as a result of actions taken to protect one's own life, it's possible that the killer can escape legal consequences for the killing. The requirements for a self-defense argument vary between cases and jurisdictions, but there are a few general rules applicable to most self-defense situations.
First, the defendant must be in a place that they had a right to be in when the situation arose. A trespasser, for example, cannot enter someone's property and then claim self-defense if they kill the property owner in a scuffle.
Second, the general rule is that the person claiming self-defense must not have provoked the slain party in any way. If the situation arose because of the actions of the eventual killer, the killer cannot argue that the slaying occurred in self-defense. It might lessen the severity of the charge, but provocation by the defendant negates the possibility of an acquittal because of self-defense.
In addition, the person acting in self-defense must have had a reasonable fear of death or great bodily harm that necessitated the use of force. If the situation would not result in death or great bodily harm, or if the killers fear was unreasonable, then the self-defense argument is not available. Furthermore, a person can only justify self-defense if the situation requires immediate action in order to prevent bodily harm or loss of life. Thus, once the situation has ceased to threaten bodily harm or loss of life, the self-defense justification is no longer available.
Some states also require that the person claiming self-defense retreat from the danger or otherwise attempt to defuse the situation before using force to protect themselves. If the person claiming self defense doesn't attempt to retreat from the threat, the self-defense argument may not be available. Some states, on the other hand, have "stand your ground" laws, which remove the duty to retreat.
Second Degree Murder Defenses: Intoxication
When referring to criminal defenses, there are two basic kinds of intoxication: voluntary and involuntary. Voluntary intoxication refers to intoxication that an individual has chosen to engage in, such as getting drunk with friends at a bar. Involuntary intoxication occurs when a person becomes intoxicated for reasons outside of their control, usually after being drugged by someone else.
People often claim that, because they were drunk or otherwise intoxicated when committing a crime, they shouldn't be punished for it. Generally, however, voluntary intoxication isn't an excuse for committing a crime, and second degree murder is no different.
In some states, intoxication becomes a factor when determining degrees of homicides, though, so it's possible that a second degree murder charge could be reduced on the basis of the defendant's intoxication at the time of the slaying. This cuts both ways, however, and the defendant's intoxication may also constitute an aggravating factor in the killing.
Involuntary intoxication will relieve a defendant of responsibility for a killing in most instances. However, the difficulty lies in proving that intoxication was involuntary. If the defendant engaged in any voluntary intoxication, then the entire intoxication is considered voluntary.
Many people try to claim that alcoholism or drug addiction rendered their intoxication involuntary since they couldn't help but follow the compulsion to drink or do drugs. This argument is almost never successful. However, if a person suffers from a mental defect as a result of their drug or alcohol addiction, they may be able to use the insanity defense discussed above.
Learn More About Second Degree Murder Defenses: Talk to a Lawyer
As you can see, there are a number of defenses to second degree murder charges. Whether one or several, apply in your case depends on the evidence. A qualified attorney who has experience in murder cases can be your strongest ally and can help you determine your best defenses or possibly negotiate a plea deal with the prosecution to reduce the charges. Speak with a criminal defense attorney in your area today.